Skip to main content

Manager conversations · 3 min read · Instant IR

How to prepare for a difficult conversation with an employee

General information only — not legal advice about your situation.

The conversation becomes harder each time it is postponed

You know an issue needs to be raised, but you are unsure how to begin or how the employee may react. The meeting stays in the “later” basket while the problem continues.

Preparation does not mean scripting every word. It means knowing the purpose, bringing clear examples and leaving enough room to hear something you did not expect.

Be clear about the purpose

Is this an informal conversation to clarify an expectation, provide feedback or follow up an earlier discussion? Or are you considering a warning, investigating an allegation or managing ongoing performance?

The invitation and process should match the real purpose. Do not call the meeting an informal catch-up if disciplinary action is already being considered.

Prepare facts, not labels

Choose a small number of examples you can explain accurately. Identify what happened, when it occurred and the effect on the work. Check whether the employee knew the expected standard and had the tools or instructions to meet it.

Instead of saying, “Your communication is poor,” explain that two customer deadline changes were not placed in the shared job notes, leaving another employee working from the old dates.

Choose the right setting and opening

Meet privately and allow enough time so the conversation is not rushed. Explain the purpose beforehand and check any relevant policy or support-person arrangements.

A clear opening might be: “I want to discuss how customer deadline changes are recorded. I have two examples, and I would like to hear your view before we decide the next steps.”

Listen before choosing the next step

Ask what happened and what affected the work. An unclear instruction, competing priority or skills gap may change your understanding. The meeting should not be a speech with a question added at the end.

Explain the expectation and discuss practical support. If something needs checking, say so. A useful meeting can finish with a further enquiry or proposed action rather than a manufactured agreement.

Record and follow through

Keep a short record of the examples, the employee’s response and the next steps. State who will do what and when. Separate agreed actions from proposals.

Choose the process that fits what happens next. An informal conversation is intended to create clarity and follow-through, not automatically produce a warning.

Official guidance

The Manager Conversations Mini Pack provides guidance and Word tools for preparation, invitation, discussion records and follow-up.

Try the free Difficult Conversation Planner

Related articles

InstantIR

Industrial relations. Without the hourly rate. Tailored workplace policies, documents and practical guidance for Australian businesses.

Instant IR · ABN 80 800 846 153

support@instantir.com.au

All prices are final totals in Australian dollars. No GST is charged.

Instant IR provides structured workplace documents and practical guidance for the selected product. It is not legal advice about the particular risks or outcome of a workplace matter. Check the requirements that apply to your business and consider professional advice where needed.

© 2026 Instant IR