Skip to main content

Poor Performance · 2 min read · Instant IR

Managing poor performance with clear expectations and a fair process

General information only — not legal advice about your situation.

Performance problems rarely fix themselves

A business owner may notice work that is not meeting the required standard.

They miss deadlines.

Their quality of work is inconsistent.

Customers complain.

Other team members become frustrated.

A difficult conversation can be a reason to delay addressing an issue.

Unfortunately, avoiding the discussion often makes things worse for everyone involved.

What poor performance actually looks like

Poor performance is not just missing sales targets.

It may include:

  • Incomplete work
  • Excessive errors
  • Poor customer service
  • Ongoing lateness
  • Failure to meet deadlines
  • Not following procedures
  • Lack of productivity
  • Failure to achieve agreed objectives

The important thing is to focus on facts rather than opinions.

"Poor attitude" is difficult to manage.

Specific examples of behaviour and outcomes are much easier.

Before you start: ask why

Many performance issues have an underlying cause.

For example:

  • Unclear expectations
  • Inadequate training
  • Personal difficulties
  • Health issues
  • Poor supervision
  • Workplace conflict
  • Lack of resources

Understanding the cause helps determine the right solution.

The performance management process

Step 1: Identify the problem

Be specific.

What standard is not being met?

How is performance falling short?

Step 2: Meet with the employee

Explain your concerns clearly.

Focus on:

  • Behaviour
  • Results
  • Expectations

Avoid personal criticism.

Step 3: Listen

Give the employee an opportunity to explain.

Skipping this step can leave relevant information unexplored.

Step 4: Agree the improvements

Agree on the improvements required and the support available. Where appropriate, record these in a formal performance improvement plan. Clearly outline:

  • What must improve
  • How improvement will be measured
  • Timeframes
  • Support offered

Step 5: Follow up

Performance management is not a single conversation.

Regular reviews are essential.

Common mistakes managers make

Process errors to avoid include:

  • Giving vague feedback
  • Failing to document discussions
  • Inconsistent treatment
  • Waiting too long
  • Jumping straight to warnings
  • Ignoring underlying causes

Good performance management focuses on improvement, not punishment.

When warnings become necessary

If informal coaching does not achieve improvement, formal action may be appropriate. Consider the employee’s response and the relevant circumstances before deciding whether a warning is appropriate.

Warnings should clearly explain:

  • The issue
  • Required improvements
  • Timeframes
  • Consequences if performance does not improve

Explain the concerns and expectations clearly before reviewing progress.

Why documentation matters

If termination eventually becomes necessary, clear records of the steps taken, information considered and decisions made help you explain how the decision was reached.

A simple note today can save significant time and cost later.

Official guidance

The Instant IR Performance Pack provides practical guidance and tailored Word tools to help you set expectations, discuss support and review performance, with an optional performance improvement plan. Your answers determine the documents prepared for the matter; review them before use.

Try the free Performance Goal Builder

Related articles

InstantIR

Industrial relations. Without the hourly rate. Tailored workplace policies, documents and practical guidance for Australian businesses.

Instant IR · ABN 80 800 846 153

support@instantir.com.au

All prices are final totals in Australian dollars. No GST is charged.

Instant IR provides structured workplace documents and practical guidance for the selected product. It is not legal advice about the particular risks or outcome of a workplace matter. Check the requirements that apply to your business and consider professional advice where needed.

© 2026 Instant IR